Domain Pigeon, as it currently stands, is ugly.
My standard is this: Imagine standing by while someone whose opinion you hold in extremely high regards meticulously reviews your work. If you can imagine yourself standing there confidently without worrying about what what he or she will find, you’ve probably got a great product. If, on the other hand, you imagine yourself thinking up excuses for why your product is not up to par, then you’ve probably got work left to do.
In Domain Pigeon’s case, I imagine myself saying “Well, I only launched it a week ago. Here’s what I’ve got planned for the future…” Instead, I want to say, “Look here, this is what I’ve accomplished.”